Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Monday, June 14, 2010

Stripping Bare the Body

... by Mark Danner

A month or so ago I found myself in the local Border's, walking the aisles waiting for something or someone, and happened to see Mark Danner's book displayed on one of the shelves. This surprised me at the time— political journalists don't typically command much attention from booksellers, especially ones like Danner, who don't blow horns for those in power. But he's a Bay Area local, and this was Palo Alto after all, so it did make some kind of sense. Of course, I had to buy it.

I've been a subscriber to the New York Review of Books for a long time, since I was in my late 20's. Somehow I'd managed to get through college and several years of work without taking a strong, public position on any political issue. But a colleague of mine at the time, Sha Xin Wei, was fond of political discourse, and through the encouragement of his example I slowly started to take sides on issues of the day. He subscribed to the NYRB, loaned me some issues, and I eventually subscribed myself. Though eventually I dropped most of my many magazine subscriptions, I've kept the NYRB (and the New Yorker). So it was that I was fortunate enough to read Mark Danner's articles during the Iraq War.

I came of age just as Nixon resigned. I remember the Viet Nam body counts on the TV every evening at the dinner table, the asassinations of Martin Luther King and of Bobby Kennedy, the assurances by Henry Kissinger that "peace was at hand" in the lead-up to the election in '72, the secret Christmas bombings in Cambodia, my mother's occasional swearing at the TV... I was 14. If ever there was an era to make you cynical about politics, that was it. Then on into the mid-70's, with drug burn-outs on every street corner putting the lie to the tune-in/turn on/drop out sex/drugs/rock'n'roll mantra floated by folks cashing in on the late 60's hippie mystique. Then to the 80's and the Reagan era— the shining city on a hill, tax cuts combined with increasing military expenditures, trickle-down economics, massive debt, presided over by a congenial but uninformed TV personality turned politician. Cynicism about politics and social movements is second nature to me (btw, if you ask me cynicism gets an undeservedly bad rap). But even I was unprepared for the strident, overweening mendacity of the Bush presidency and the ease and completeness with which it swept aside all rational, informed discussion among the media and power elites who shape the political climate in the US. What a dismal, dismal time it was.

Mark Danner was one of the very few who kept my spirits up. Now, that's an odd way to put it, because he often brought some very discouraging and chilling news. But he also brought his deep moral clarity and understanding of war, what it means to those who wage it and are caught within it. I cannot begin to describe what relief it was, reading his articles and understanding that he knew what suffering was being wrought, knew it and abhorred it. The way politicians and pundits talk about war, like a football game— an event you go to, participate in, and leave— well, it's just nauseating. People like Condi Rice, Donald Rumsfeld, Dick Cheney, talking tough, making the "tough" choices— there's no true understanding, no empathy, in these people. They just do not appreciate, nor do they care to appreciate, the human consequences that result from the choices they make. It is their very job not to understand these things— otherwise they could never wield or retain power.

Mark Danner does understand. It comes through in his writings. He's not strident, not accusatory. He's informed, rational, clear, calm, methodical— and moral. His style of journalism requires that the journalist not only investigate and report the facts as fully as he can, but also bear witness to the events that unfold.

So, I was curious about the book. What else had he written? "Stripping Bare the Body" is a collection of his war reporting over the last two-and-a-half decades. The pieces, he says, are for the most part presented as originally written. I can't find at the moment information about where each piece was published, though the introduction says he was in Haiti on assignment for the New Yorker in when he was doing work on the first piece, "The Legacy", published in '89. (Turns out he, like me, was born in 1958, so he was 31 then.) This chapter describes, first hand, in chilling and bloody detail, killings and anarchy during the first few years of military rule after Baby Doc Duvalier was removed from power in '86. It's difficult for me to imagine living and reporting in such an environment. I, at age 31, was a new father and still (as now) unformed and immature in many ways. I would have neither the courage nor the ability to live and report in such a place. But I can imagine what impact that would have upon one, the first-hand experience of the rawness of violence and power. He's quite aware that he's protected, but just barely, by the thin bubble of his whiteness and foreignness. Just reading this is exhausting, experiencing it must have been several orders of magnitude more so.

It's a long book, around 600 pages not counting the references and end notes. I've only read the Haitian sections so far. Following those are pieces from Sarajevo, another sterling period and place in human history. I'm looking forward to the rest of the book with an admixture of dread, but I read these stories because I must— you can't truly know our times without knowing these things, our humanity demands it— and because they are so compellingly written.

George Packer's review in the NYT is not positive. While commending the early first-hand reporting, he's critical of the later work based on other sources. There's more going on here than just a book review, of course, George Packer (and the NYT) was an early supporter of the Iraq war, one of the "Liberal Hawks" along with folks like Tom Friedman. These people were, shall we say, a bit overcome by their anti-Saddam fervor and forgot what they should have learned about politics and war growing up in the Vietnam era— good intentions aren't enough, and none of the actors has completely good intentions in the first place. We'll see what I think when I finish the book.

Sunday, November 15, 2009

Ground Truth

Just read "The Ground Truth" by John Farmer, about what the 9/11 commission was able to find out about the events around the 9/11 attacks. I picked it up from the library on a whim, just because there was a blurb from William Langewiesche on the back.

In brief, the book summarizes discrepancies between the actual series of events and the version presented in the days and weeks following 9/11, which has become the dominant narrative of those days. He provides transcripts of logs/tapes and compares them with official statements. As I read it, his overarching conclusion is that government fails to prepare for and react to catastrophe because it refuses to publicly acknowledge and thoroughly address mistakes. This causes a failure to prepare adequately, which increases the likelihood of future mistakes.

I suppose there are those within government who expect it to function better than this. Mr. Farmer was attorney general of New Jersey, and served as counsel to the 9/11 commission, and certainly seems to feel it should. His book ends with some recommendations for 'reinventing government', basically by trying to bring policies in line with what actually happens during a crisis. But from what I've experienced in my (mercifully) limited experience with bureaucracy and government, these failures come as no surprise. The primary objective of most organizations is CYA&mdash' "cover your ass" — and the primary goal of high-level figures in government is to construct a narrative of events that reaffirms their importance and effectiveness. The Bush administration was not different from previous administrations in kind, and only perhaps to degree. That they lied to the press and to the commission in order to make themselves look good, well, that was standard operating procedure for them. It's always easy for the powerful to conflate their own interests with the interests of the organization they manage or those it serves. I'm sure they felt that providing a reassuring, if false, narrative of how the government was in control of events was best for the country, and if it was 'incidentally' also in their own self-interests, well, what's the big deal?

Fundamentally I see this as a divide between those who get things done, and those who take credit. Those who get things done have to pay attention to reality, because if they don't, ultimately their efforts will fail. Their goal is to effect a change in reality. Those who take credit pay attention only to how things are perceived, and their goal is to effect a change in perception. There's a symbiosis and a tension between these groups. The symbiosis is due to the fact that in order to marshal the resources to get big things done, the perception has to be created that the change is necessary, and that the people in charge know what they're doing. And in order to manufacture the perception, there has to be a germ of reality that the manufacturers of perception can leverage (well, some of the time, anyway). To the extent that people can perceive the reality, it can't diverge too much from the perception. So, there's the symbiosis, which is, I suppose, obvious. The tension is yet more obvious— the doers need to acknowledge and learn from mistakes, while their counterparts need to hide them. Thus the 9/11 commission wants to learn all the facts so that it can address the problems, while the white house and the military want to keep the inconvenient facts hidden.

They also operate at different time scales— the doers operate long-term, while their counterparts operate short-term. From the perspective of those who take credit, delaying apprehension of inconvenient facts is sufficient. They appreciate that information has time value, and that the information available while the narrative is being formed is the most important, because the narrative, once formed and widely adopted, will persist. Thus immediate suppression of inconvenient facts is the goal. The trickle of books that come out years later (as this one did) is not really of interest to those who shape the narrative, because they know that after sufficient time most people have lost interest— their perceptions will have been set, the narrative established. So, for example, the narrative of 9/11 is that we were attacked by evil, wily foes who had the advantage of surprise, but that the government, at all levels and especially at the highest levels, reacted swiftly and effectively to protect us. Once this narrative was established, they just had to delay until the actual information no longer mattered. Thus the delay in, and timing of the release of, the results of the investigations in response to the 9/11 commission findings.

Farmer notes, for example, that the narrative has our F-16's tracking flight 168, ready to shoot it down if need be, when the passengers assaulted the cabin and the plane went down during a struggle with the hijackers. The central issue there is the difficult decisions the leaders must face in determining whether to sacrifice the lives of those on board the plane. This narrative affirms that the military and government was in control, and that the leaders were making quick, informed decisions and wrestling with large moral issues under time pressure. In reality, he points out, we didn't even know where flight 168 was, had no F-16's anywhere near the aircraft, the plane had gone down before the leaders even knew it existed, and the eventual directive to take down the plane if necessary was never passed to the pilots because the military official in charge knew that there were no suspect planes currently in the air when the order arrived.

Being allied, as I am, with the 'reality-based community', I agree with Farmer that the facts need to be acknowledged and addressed. But I cannot share his surprise (though I share his dismay) that they were not. And while I appreciate his suggestions for improvement, I think he doesn't fully appreciate the reality that must be addressed. The "ground truth" is that those who wield power do so because they know that perception matters, and know how to manage it. The only way to make reality drive policy is to make reality drive perception, and it can only do so when the facts are timely and relevant. I'm glad he wrote the book, and it's a small push in the right direction, but it's too little, too late. It won't be read except by those who still care, and they are few and wield relatively little power. Priorities won't change, and policies that align better with demands won't be effected. Guess I'm pessimistic, or perhaps a cynic, but that's how it's always been.

p.s. Also read "The Atomic Bazaar" by William Langewiesche. I'll write about these soon, I need to return these books to the library before it closes.

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Obama's address to congress on health care

Just watched Obama's address, thanks to the wonders of YouTube. It's available at WhiteHouse.gov, along with a transcript.

Most of it ran as these things usually do. Lots of interruptions for applause, with various members or factions making a show of standing and applauding or sitting and looking stoic, depending on the side they're taking. I find this posturing to be a bit wearying... As his speech progressed he moved from descriptions of what he wanted reform to achieve, to what particular proposals he favored, to a description of the partisan bickering and fear-mongering, to a rousing call to action and American ideals. It had a good overall flow and structure. I was rather interested that he chose to call out and address some of the lies (his word) promulgated by opponents of his proposals. His directness, I think, reveals his frustration with the level of debate and the kind of politics being waged. And his final call to action and appeal to ideals and morality during the last ten minutes of his speech was quite strong. It's an appeal that I'm pretty amenable to, of course, but I think you can't deny that he performed very well. So in the end I felt it was pretty watchable.

A few days ago I watched his address to schoolchildren, also on YouTube. With both speeches I felt he needed to be a bit more camera-savvy. Reagan always knew to address the camera (he was a professional pitchman after all). Obama looks left and right at the audience, and clearly connects with them, but rarely, if ever, looks directly at the camera. As a result the feeling is that you're observing him talk to others, rather than listening to him talk to you. It's clear he has the charisma— his resolve and passion was quite in evidence with this speech— but he needs to figure out how to deploy it a bit better through the media.

Since I don't watch TV new or talking head shows, and get only a very biased view via reddit and web news aggregator headlines, I don't really know how this played out. Fox "News" probably didn't play it live at all, and I doubt there was much analysis on any program of what he said, as opposed to descriptions of how various factions received him, and talking heads trying to spin it this way or that. My sense is that it didn't move the national conversation quite as much as he needs to. It did seem to energize his base a bit, which I think he needs. Energized me to write this, anyway, though of course that's not saying much!

I don't know enough to assess the financial impact of what he proposes. What is clear is that he's trying to do this the right way, with the expenses budgeted and paid for, rather than through keeping it off books or pushing costs off into the nebulous future as we've done with the Afghanistan and Iraq wars. I'm not sure he's going to be able to save as much by reforming the system as he hopes— the folks extracting profits out of the current system are going to hold onto them as tightly as they can. Also, I suspect that much of the "waste" comes from the complexity of the billing and paperwork, which isn't going to go away if we continue to have multiple insurance policies with varying level of coverage and forms of payment as we do now. I suspect a lot of push towards higher costs comes from defensive tests and incentives (or lack of disincentives) for doctors to perform, and clients to request, procedures that aren't strongly indicated. Overly-aggressive end-of-life treatment clearly contributes its share of unnecessary cost, too, but that's a societal issue that's not easily addressed. High pharmaceutical prices due to non-competitive restrictions on bargaining are also a problem; he might be able to do something about this, though again big pharma is going to fight this with everything they've got. So these seem like large contributions to the problem of escalating health care costs that I don't see being addressed. But I really don't know how much of the overall cost is due to these features of our system, and how much is due to "waste and abuse" (or less prejudicially, how the system is gamed) by the people participating in the system— for example, when healthy people opt out of the system and rely on emergency room service, throwing costs onto others, or when insurers cherry-pick who they insure. I wonder if anyone really knows. I should explore the web a bit more, I'm sure there's data somewhere that would inform these kinds of speculations.

Anyway, I liked the speech. It was passionate and direct. He's a very bright guy, Obama is, and curiously optimistic still despite the difficult slog over the summer. Let's hope he succeeds.

Monday, August 31, 2009

The Years of Talking Dangerously by Geoffrey Nunberg

I finally decided to find something more productive to do on the web than play sudoku and read reddit— namely, to get off the web and read books for a change. As it happens for my birthday my wife gave me a copy of Geoffrey Nunberg's book (he's the linguist who comments on Fresh Air) so the choice of where to start was easy. It turns out to be a selection of his on-air commentaries over the past eight or so years, slightly edited (or unedited, as some were a little too explicit for NPR). I was dubious at first, but I decided to try it. Being a typical educated older liberal San Francisco Bay Area resident, I listen to NPR all the time, so I was familiar with his commentaries. I'd always found them just OK; somehow I'd never really taken to them.

As it turns out, though, I find myself enjoying the book quite a bit. Partly, I'm embarrassed to say, I suspect a significant factor in my former lukewarm reception was that I'm just not that fond of his voice and reading style. It comes across as a bit mannered to me, and overemphasized the wordplay— instead of being witty it seemed, well, a bit too cute and attention-grabbing. But this all goes down much better when I read the commentaries instead of listen to them. I find I can appreciate the ideas and observations better at reading speed, where I can pause to think and reflect on what he's saying. As a result I've found that much of my frustration with the way many members of the Bush administration (well, all members the Bush administration) manipulated language for political purposes, which I had had difficulty articulating, he was able to articulate quite clearly and forcefully. I'd understood this, vaguely, nodding along listening to NPR years ago, but it became startlingly obvious to me when reading the essays in print. He put his finger on exactly the things that had troubled me! Imagine that!

Now, as a book, or even a collection of essays, it's pretty light reading. Owing to their origin as short radio pieces, none of the commentaries is particularly deep or involved. (Perhaps that's what I need to wean myself off the 'net and back into print.) But they do provide amusement and plenty of brief insights into how the English language is used in America today. I've been enjoying it.

At Powell's Books